- Home
- Equipment
- Industries
- We Immay
- Resource
- Contact
Author: Site Editor Publish Time: 2025-05-28 Origin: Site
Many consumers mistakenly assume that hand soap and hand sanitizer are interchangeable. In reality, they serve different purposes and operate through distinct mechanisms. This confusion can lead to improper use and reduced effectiveness in maintaining hand hygiene.
Understanding the difference is especially important because each product is designed for specific environments and usage scenarios. Hand soap is formulated for removing dirt, grease, and microbes through rinsing, while hand sanitizer is meant for quick disinfection when water isn’t available.
By clearly distinguishing between the two, both individuals and industries can make more informed choices—improving hygiene efficiency, supporting health and safety, and optimizing the use of related equipment and production processes.
Let’s take a closer look at how hand soap and hand sanitizer differ in terms of formulation. While both serve to clean or disinfect hands, their core ingredients and working principles are fundamentally different.
2.1 Hand Soap Composition and Function
Hand soap is typically a water-based formulation containing:
Surfactants (like SLES or coco-glucoside): to break down and lift away dirt, oil, and microbes
Moisturizers (such as glycerin or aloe vera): to protect the skin from drying out
Thickeners (e.g., salt or cellulose derivatives): to give the product a pleasant viscosity
Fragrances and preservatives: for consumer appeal and product stability
Hand soap works by emulsifying contaminants and suspending them in water, allowing them to be rinsed off effectively.
2.2 Hand Sanitizer Composition and Function
Hand sanitizers are alcohol-based or alcohol-free gels or liquids. Common ingredients include:
Alcohol (ethanol or isopropyl alcohol, 60–75%): the primary disinfectant
Thickening agents (such as carbomer): to form a gel structure
Moisturizers (like glycerin or propylene glycol): to counteract alcohol’s drying effect
Neutralizers (like triethanolamine): to balance pH and activate thickening agents
Unlike hand soap, hand sanitizer doesn’t remove dirt but kills most germs on contact without the need for water.
Although both hand soap and hand sanitizer are liquid or semi-liquid hygiene products, their production processes vary significantly due to differences in viscosity, ingredients, and emulsification requirements.
3.1 Hand Soap Manufacturing Process
The production of hand soap involves blending surfactants, conditioning agents, and thickeners into a water-based solution. The process typically includes mild heating and controlled shear to ensure complete dissolution and uniformity.
Heating and premixing of water phase
Deionized water is first heated in a stainless steel mixing tank with gentle agitation. Surfactants such as SLES or coco betaine are gradually introduced to ensure thorough blending.
High-shear mixing for thickeners
Viscosity modifiers like salt or cellulose-based thickeners are added under high-shear homogenization. This step prevents clumping and ensures even hydration.
Cooling and post-addition of sensitive ingredients
Once the core ingredients are fully mixed, the batch is cooled to a suitable temperature before introducing heat-sensitive components such as fragrance, dyes, or preservatives.
Low-speed mixing after sensitive ingredients
After heat-sensitive ingredients such as fragrance, dyes, or preservatives are added, the batch should be gently stirred at low speed for several minutes. This ensures uniform distribution of these components throughout the mixture. Low-speed agitation also helps preserve the integrity of sensitive ingredients, maintaining both product appearance and stability.
Recommended equipment:
Jacketed stainless steel mixing tanks with top agitators and bottom high shear homogenizers.
3.2 Hand Sanitizer Manufacturing Process
The production of alcohol-based hand sanitizer involves careful control of mixing parameters to ensure product efficacy, clarity, and stability. The typical process includes the following steps:
Low-Speed Mixing
Deionized water, moisturizers (such as glycerin), and gelling agents like carbomer are first combined using a low-speed mixer. This initial step ensures uniform dispersion of powders and prevents clumping.
High Shear Homogenization
The mixture is then subjected to high-shear homogenization to fully dissolve the thickening agents and create a smooth, consistent gel base. This step improves the texture and stability of the formulation.
Vacuum Deaeration
During or after homogenization, vacuum is applied to remove trapped air bubbles. This deaeration is critical for maintaining product clarity.
pH Adjustment with Neutralizers
Under a closed environment, neutralizing agents such as triethanolamine are added. This step activates the thickening agents, setting the desired viscosity and gel structure.
Alcohol Incorporation in a Closed System
Finally, ethanol or isopropyl alcohol is slowly added to the formulation within a sealed system to minimize evaporation and maintain disinfectant potency.
Gentle Final Mixing
A light mixing step ensures thorough blending, preserving the product’s clarity and homogeneity.
Recommended Equipment
Vacuum cream mixers equipped with both low-speed agitators and high-shear homogenizers.
The key to selecting the right mixer lies in understanding the different process requirements of hand soap and hand sanitizer production. While both products rely on effective mixing and homogenization, their specific formulation and process needs lead to different equipment configurations.
Key Process Factors to Consider:
Heating Capability
Hand soap production typically requires heating to dissolve surfactants and thickeners—usually between 60°C and 75°C.
➤ Required for hand soap, not needed for hand sanitizer.
Vacuum System
Vacuum is important in both processes to eliminate air bubbles—critical for product clarity and smooth filling.
➤ Recommended for both, especially in clear or premium-grade formulations.
High Shear Homogenization
Both products benefit from high-shear mixing. For hand soap, it improves emulsion stability when incorporating oils. For hand sanitizer, it ensures the carbomer or thickener is fully activated and evenly dispersed.
➤ Required for both.
Closed Tank Design
Alcohol-based hand sanitizer should be processed in a sealed system to prevent evaporation and ensure safety.
➤ Critical for hand sanitizer, not necessary for hand soap.
Wall Scraper Agitator
Both hand soap and hand sanitizer benefit from a wall scraper agitator. For hand soap, it ensures even heat distribution and complete mixing of viscous materials. For hand sanitizer, it helps avoid buildup of thickening agents like carbomer on the vessel walls, improving overall blend uniformity.
➤ Recommended for both.
Of course, if your formulation has special requirements, we can customize exclusive mixing equipment solutions for you.
In both personal and industrial hygiene, understanding the differences between hand soap and hand sanitizer is more than academic—it’s essential for choosing the right manufacturing equipment.
From heated emulsification for hand soap to closed-system mixing for hand sanitizer, each formulation has its own processing challenges. Both products benefit from vacuum deaeration, high-shear homogenization, and wall-scraping agitation to ensure consistent quality, clarity, and stability.
IMMAY is a professional manufacturer of hand soap and hand sanitizer mixing machines, offering solutions tailored to hot and cold blending processes. Our systems are engineered to support precise temperature control, vacuum functionality, and custom agitator designs.
Whether you're producing gel-based hand sanitizers or fragranced liquid hand soaps, IMMAY’s mixers provide the process control and hygiene standard you need for reliable, mass production.
Contact IMMAY today to explore how our mixing equipment can improve your workflow and meet the demands of your hand sanitizer or liquid hand soap production line.
